The Best Pizza in Dublin, Ohio: Local Favorites Worth Trying
Dublin’s pizza scene runs wider than most people expect from a Columbus suburb — a long-running family-owned Italian spot, a wood-fired favorite with locations across the state, and a handful of neighborhood pizzerias locals swear by but visitors rarely find on their own. I put this list together the way I’d tell a client where to order on their first night in a new house.
I’m Jacob Bates, a Realtor with Di Lusso Real Estate, and after enough years working this market, I’ve got opinions about where to get a good pie in Dublin. Here’s the rundown.
Best Family-Owned Classic: Enrico’s Pizza & Restaurant
Enrico’s Pizza & Restaurant has been serving Dublin for decades as a genuinely family-owned Italian kitchen, and it consistently comes up as locals’ pick for the most authentic pizza in the city — the kind of place where the recipe hasn’t changed because it never needed to.
Best Wood-Fired Pie: Harvest Pizzeria
Harvest Pizzeria (45 N. High St., Historic Dublin) is part of a small Ohio-based chain, but the Dublin location holds its own — specialty pies and a build-your-own option cooked in a wood-fired oven, with the All-the-Way Pizza (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, and green pepper) a consistent local favorite.
Best Upscale, Date-Night Pizza: Valentina’s at Bridge Park
Valentina’s at Bridge Park brings an authentic Italian countryside feel to its pizza program, and its Margherita has earned some of the strongest praise of any pie in the city — festive, upbeat atmosphere included, making it a strong pick if you want pizza with a bit more polish.
Best Neighborhood Pizzeria: Bridge Street Pizza
Bridge Street Pizza is the kind of spot locals mention with real loyalty — thick, topping-loaded pies, solid wings, and a reputation for coming through big for group orders, even if the phone lines can get busy on a Friday night.
Best Hidden Gem: Black Dog Pizzeria
Black Dog Pizzeria shows up again and again in local “best kept secret” conversations — smaller and less flashy than the bigger names, but consistently mentioned as some of the best pizza in Central Ohio by the people who’ve actually found it.
Best NY-Style Slice: Tommy’s Pizza
Tommy’s Pizza is the spot to know if you’re craving an actual New York-style slice — foldable, cheese-forward, and served hot, with a build that stands apart from the more Midwest-style pies elsewhere on this list.
Best Wood-Fired Flatbread & Mediterranean Twist: Al Manakeesh
For something outside the traditional pizza lane, Al Manakeesh serves wood-fired flatbreads with Mediterranean toppings like za’atar and labneh — a good change of pace if you want the wood-fired char without a classic red-sauce pie.
Best for Quick Pickup or Delivery: Donatos and Romeo’s Pizza
For a reliable, no-fuss order, Dublin has strong local outposts of two Ohio pizza institutions: Donatos Pizza, known for edge-to-edge toppings on a thin crust, and Romeo’s Pizza, a Medina-born Ohio chain with a loyal following of its own.
Plan a Dublin Pizza Crawl
Because Historic Dublin and Bridge Park sit so close together, it’s easy to turn this list into an afternoon — start with a slice at Tommy’s, walk to Harvest Pizzeria for a full pie, and save Valentina’s for a proper sit-down dinner later that night. Pair it with a stop on the Celtic Cocktail Trail and you’ve got a full day mapped out without moving your car more than once.
A Good Food Scene Says a Lot About a Neighborhood
Whether it’s a 35-year-old family kitchen or a wood-fired newcomer, the pizza scene in Dublin reflects the same thing its housing market does — a mix of long-standing local character and steady new growth. If that kind of neighborhood texture matters to you in a home search, I’d be glad to walk you through what living in Dublin actually looks like day to day. I’m Jacob Bates, Realtor with Di Lusso Real Estate — reach out anytime.
This article is part of an ongoing series covering every neighborhood in Greater Columbus. Explore more local guides to find the right fit for your next move.
